Tax me to help us

This is not my typical post. I came across the following rather interesting news story on the BBC website and thought of sharing it with the readers of this blog. What are your thoughts? 

Rich Germans demand higher taxes

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/8321967.stm

A group of rich Germans has launched a petition calling for the government to make wealthy people pay higher taxes.

The group say they have more money than they need, and the extra revenue could fund economic and social programmes to aid Germany’s economic recovery.

Germany could raise 100bn euros (£91bn) if the richest people paid a 5% wealth tax for two years, they say.

The petition has 44 signatories so far, and will be presented to newly re-elected Chancellor Angela Merkel.

The group say the financial crisis is leading to an increase in unemployment, poverty and social inequality.

Simply donating money to deal with the problems is not enough, they want a change in the whole approach.

“The path out of the crisis must be paved with massive investment in ecology, education and social justice,” they say in the petition.

Those who had “made a fortune through inheritance, hard work, hard-working, successful entrepreneurship, or investment” should contribute by paying more to alleviate the crisis.

The man behind the petition, Dieter Lehmkuhl, told Berlin’s Tagesspiegel that there were 2.2 million people in Germany with a fortune of more than 500,000 euros.

If they all paid the tax for two years, Germany could raise 100bn euros to fund ecological programmes, education and social projects, said the retired doctor and heir to a brewery.

Signatory Peter Vollmer told AFP news agency he was supporting the proposal because he had inherited “a lot of money I do not need”.

He said the tax would be “a viable and socially acceptable way out of the flagrant budget crisis”.

The group held a demonstration in Berlin on Wednesday to draw attention to their plans, throwing fake banknotes into the air.

Mr Vollmer said it was “really strange that so few people came”.

The real bailout prescription

Banks Only

It seems like I am in a statistical state-of-mind lately.
If you were to go to the IRS website you will find the total number of Individual Income Tax Returns for the year 2008 is: 156,297,000 (Source: http://www.irs.gov/taxstats/ –>Filing Season Statistics –>Filing Season Weekly Reports –> Report for filing year 2008 –> End of Year End Report.)

Let’s take the top 25% of tax payers out and we are left with 117 million individuals.
Next, let’s take the $3.8 Trillion (anticipated government spending across current and pending stimulus and bailouts including Bush bailout) and distribute it evenly to the 117M individuals that filed taxes.

You will arrive at the astounding number of $32,478!

That’s what we all could have gotten (except for the top 25% of earners who shouldn’t need it) instead of the current morass of bailouts and stimulus.

Let’s play this hypothetical scenario out a little further:
Imagine how fast our economy would have recovered if we were given this money, income tax free in a special account, to spend within two years within United States including purchase of airline tickets to fly out of United States (money spent abroad will not count). For any one with credit card loan or mortgage default, there would be additional stipulation that they pay off the loans/mortgage first. I am sure IRS can think of many other stipulations (and that would be fine). At the end of each of the two years we all would have to submit receipts to ensure we complied with the stipulations.

Continue reading